Private, U.S. Army
On November 14, 1805, Alexander Willard and George Shannon experienced one of the more fortunate coincidences that occurred during the entire Expedition. Because of the almost continuously stormy weather, visibility was so poor, and navigation in the heavily loaded dugout canoes they had left (one had been destroyed by waves that drove it against the rocks on the shore) that it was hard to determine whether to stay where they were or proceed on. George Vancouver's chart of the Lower Columbia River was in such a small scale as to be virtually useless for navigation. With Colter, they had left "Dismal Nitch" (east of Point Ellice, at today's Megler Point, Washington) the previous day, assigned by Captain Clark to find a more sheltered harbor to camp in, and also to look for whites at a trading post or with a ship. Seeing neither any white men nor any place that seemed better than their present campsite east of "Point Distress," or "Blustering Point," Colter returned to camp with that report while Willard and Shannon pitched camp and awaited the main party. That night, while they were asleep on a "butifull Sand beech," Indians stole their rifles almost from under their heads, according to Clark. The two men threatened the departing thieves—as Nicholas Biddle added, probably from Private George Shannon's information1—with pursuit and retaliation by "a large party from above." And then, in Clark's account, "Capt. Lewis & party arrived at the Camp of those Indians at So Timely a period that the Inds. were allarmed & delivered up the guns &c."
Willard had obviously redeemed himself since July 12, 1804, when he was court–martialled for "Lying down and Sleeping on his post whilst a Sentinal, on the night of the 11th. Instant." According to the Rules and Articles of War, that was a capitol crime tantamount to desertion and punishable by death. However presumably because no dire consequences had resulted from it, he was sentenced instead to 100 lashes with a cat o' nine tails.2 An officer was to stand by and ascertain that each stroke was laid on with vigor. The purpose of a flogging was primarily to inflict pain and shame on the criminal, and to serve as a lesson to his comrades, who were required to witness the event. Therefore, ostensibly to somewhat lessen the purely physical effects of it, but also to protract the experience of the criminal and its effect on the onlookers, the sentence was usually carried out, as it was with Willard, on four successive days at sunset, 25 lashes each day, and strokes were separated by pauses equal to "three paces in slow time" as audibly measured out by drumbeats. (See also "Courts Martial on the Trail.")
A Newhampshireman, the brown-haired, dark-complexioned Willard was born in either 1777 or 78, about the time that the meteoric reputation of an eloquent and dedicated young patriot named Alexander Hamilton drew the attention and allegiance of infant Willard's father, who proudly named his son in honor of the rising statesman.
Willard joined the army in 1800 as an "artificer"—a craftsman; in his case, a blacksmith. At the age of 25, while on duty at Fort Kaskaskia in the Illinois country, he voluntarily enlisted in the Corps of Discovery. At times he apparently assisted John Shields, the expedition's primary blacksmith. In July of 1805 Clark selected Willard as one of five men to assist him in surveying and flagging the portage route around the falls of the Missouri River.2 After Clark's party reached three islands a short distance above the falls, where they set up the temporary Upper Portage Camp,3 Willard was dispatched on June 18 to pick up meat the hunters had left. Clark wrote that Willard was 170 yards from the islands when he "was attact by a white [grizzly] bear and verry near being Caught." Clark immediately summoned three of the enlisted men and "prosued the bear" as it approached the islands and threatened Colter, who retreated into the Missouri River. After that, the general location of Colter's crisis, which became the Corps' camp above the falls, was known as "White Bear Islands."
At Fort Clatsop, Willard suffered a mysterious illness from February through March 1806, complaining of headache, fever, and low spirits. He and William Bratton were sick at the same time, but unlike Bratton, Willard recovered on his own.
Clark took Willard in his advance party that sought to buy horses as the Corps moved back up the Columbia River in the spring of 1806, and occasionally ordered him to carry word back to Lewis about the continuing failure to obtain affordable steeds. Even though well aware of how precious their few horses were, Willard was the man who failed to picket his own animal well enough at The Dalles on April 19. It wandered off during the night, and could not be found the next morning; the incident aroused Lewis's wrath toward the private:
Years later, one of Willard's sons would tell historian and suffrage activist Eva Emory Dye that, when reminiscing about the expedition his father "did not speak much of Lewis but he was a personal friend of Gov. Clark" after that.4
Still, Lewis wrote with concern on August 4, 1806, when Willard was thrown into the Missouri River in eastern Montana. He and John Ordway had been hunting behind Lewis's main party and were coming up after dark with the meat from a bear and two deer in their canoe. The current pushed it into a "parsel of sawyers," or partially submerged trees, and Willard, the steersman, was swept out of it. Meanwhile, Ordway fought his way to shore a half mile downstream and returned by land. Willard had clung to a sawyer until he could tie some handy driftwood together as a float, then
Back in Missouri, five months after the expedition's end, Alex married Eleanor McDonald, a union that lasted 58 years, with Eleanor surviving him by three years. With Clark's help he obtained work as a blacksmith for the Delaware and Shawnee Indians in 1809. He also worked as a courier for Clark during the War of 1812. Eleanor bore twelve children, some of whom moved with their parents to Wisconsin in 1827. There, in 1836, their second son, George Clark Willard, was killed by a neighbor, who was convicted of manslaughter.
In 1852, at the first peak of westward migration, the extended Willard family joined a wagon train put together at Platteville, and moved to California. Alexander Willard, then 74, crossed the Missouri River for the final time at Council Bluffs, Iowa. He was 86 when he died in Sacramento,5 the next-to-last survivor of the Corps of Discovery.
2. William C. Hart, Observations on Military Law and the Constitution and Practice of Courts-Martial, (New York: Appleton & Co., 1864), pp. 244-245.
3. Moulton, ed., Journals, 4:305n1.
4. The first, Lower Portage Camp, was at the mouth of Belt Creek downstream from the falls.
5. Larry E. Morris, The Fate of the Corps: What Became of the Lewis and Clark Explorers After the Expedition (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2004), 120-21, 174-75.
6. Ibid., 172–74.
Funded in part by a grant from the National Park Service, Challenge Cost Share Program.